Sunday, March 4, 2012

Aurifil abuse: mythbusting

The prosecution has alleged that nylon monofilament thread melts under heat. Eg. Ironing. I'm not sure why you'd iron a finished quilt (am I missing something?) but I HAD to try these Aurifil invisible threads out. 

Anyway, I asked Senore Alex if he could confirm or deny the allegation. In between deciding what wine we'd have with dinner in my Aurifl coloured kitchen (don't you love how flirting is a national sport in Italy?), Alex stated emphatically that he never says anything bad about his threads but doesn't mind other people doing so. But he did refer me to a couple of posts where invisible thread had been heat tested. So I decided to indulge in a little thread S&M of my own and really put it the Aurifil through its paces. (It was masochistic because I flinched every time I put the hot iron on the thread. I'm really not good at deliberately trying to ruin things). 

Please don't call the RSPCA (Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Aurifil). 

Being mean to thread means two things to me. One - Free motion quilting. If a thread or a machine is going to flip-up (you know what I mean), it will be free-motion quilting. Two - ironing. High heat. No steam. Not being gentle. I decided I needed a test piece that I could really see the invisible thread on.

I'd been doodling a tree design from a picture I saw at a function centre in Perth. Sorry for the really bad photo, but here it is. So I decided to doodle my own version with my machine, with the dark monofilament thread on a test piece of fabric. 

First, I loaded and ran the dark monofil on a straight stitch. It worked fine. The only issue was that my Bernina 820's auto threader kept UNTHREADING the monofil immediately after threading and I wasn't fast enough to catch it in the second it was through the needle. Grr. So I ended up threading it by hand. The thing about invisible thread is... it's invisible. Or practically. So that was fun. 

I deliberately did the dark thread on light fabric so you and I could see what it did when I abused it with the iron. So here goes.

Before:
Iron on hottest setting. Hold it on for 5 seconds at a time. Eyes closed and toes crossed...
And here's the result.
Can you see that thread running across it? You know I'm appalling at cutting my thread ends off. I decided this one was useful. I couldn't really tell if any of the thread had frizzled in the stitching, so I repeated the torture with that end-thread. Let's have a closer look. Look for any frizzling, melty bits or unevenness in the thread.
Can you see any? 
Nope. I can't either.
So that is myth number 1 out the way. Aurifl nylon monofilament thread does not melt under heat.
I hope Mr Alex is happy with that!

I should point out that monofil works brilliantly with straightline quilting, not just free-motion. Particularly with bright colours where it's hard to choose the right thread.

There's still a chance to win the thread here. There are a heap of no-reply bloggers who have commented - please check your reply status if you are entering competitions. It makes it hard to track people down. 

Happy stitching!

18 comments:

  1. Oooh, you cruel person you! Funnily enough I was looking for monofilament thread the other day and the woman in the fabric shop was all worried about the iron too - really? For AFTER quilting? Strange woman! They didn't have any anyway after all that, so shall have a hunt for some of this online

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gah. I NEED this thread? Is it soft?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I haven't used nylon filament thread - it makes me think of awful polyester comforters from the 80s that fall apart except for the thick nylon thread holding the whole thing together. Is this nicer than that?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great post, Laura! I love your sense of adventure and humour. :) Ask Senior Alex if he'd like a Canadian tester. I could see how the thread holds up in extremely cold conditions. LOL.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey, did you hear that? It was the sound of YOU sucking me into another collection (I have to blame someone else, can't handle the entire burden ). OK, so the "clear" threads I have used here in the US have been "stiff" and "pokey" (shut off the peanut gallery). In reality I would cringe at using them on a quilt that was going to get snuggled in...care to do some testing on this? LOL, ok, just an opinion will do...pretty please...

    ReplyDelete
  6. I hadn't even considered an invisible thread for quilting...until this post. Fiona at florriestan@gmail.com (gotta fix my no-reply status).

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow ! I AM A CONVERT! Thanks for the testing and revealation!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Funny post - but great information. Thanks for the test drive.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for the info and giving this thread a test drive, I need some new Invisible Thread and love Aurifil threads and I think I will give this a run also.

    ReplyDelete
  10. But did you really expect anything else ?

    ReplyDelete
  11. That is great! I have feared nylon mono for that very reason. After all, when you sell items you never know what the new owner will do to it. And I don't want someone coming back saying "it melted!"

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for doing that? I was so worried ;-)) I love my Aurifil threads and would love to add this to my stash. Mary

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you for your funny response to my original post. It is gone now....hmnnn....I did say that I had a nylon thread melt...I did not say it was Aurifil...(It wasn't)....I don't iron my quilts....I use monofilament to do very invisible machine applique....it works beautifully, and then I iron after each piece to make it perfectly flat....then add another piece....just wanted to keep it real....however, you had a funny article....thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  14. What a great test Laura. Here at Aurifil Thread Australia, we have run a similar test, with the same happy results, but it is woderful to see someone else testing Aurifil's 'hair" fine monofilament.

    ReplyDelete
  15. thx for the test info--I must order some of the clear thread now! Hope I can find a place to find both the dark and light for one-stop shopping.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I am still way behind with my blog reading and am today using our public holiday (and the arrival of a damnable head cold) to read through all your posts from 1 March forward.

    Thank you for the review of the Aurifil thread, I would love to try it as I have read so many bloggers who swear by it but here in my little neck of the woods we get a choice of Gutermann, Rasant or Mettler. I have used Gutermann all my sewing life so have not tried the other two (although my quilting teacher swears by Rasant).

    ReplyDelete
  17. Use a marker to color the first 1/4" of the thread. Makes it easy to see it to thread the needle.

    ReplyDelete

Yippee - you're commenting! I _love_ comments. :) I've had so much spam lately though that I'm limiting to registered users for a bit to see if that works... If you're a friend, you can find me on Facebook and comment that way if you have trouble.